Posts Tagged: Cancer Research UK

Was my dry January for the wrong cause?

It wasn’t hard, but I’m glad it’s over: that’s the best summary I can find for taking part in the Dryathlon for the second January running. Life without alcohol felt calmer, but lacked the sharpening of mood and thought that a glass of wine can provide. The secret, of course, is to keep things moderate as the year goes on… Read more on Was my dry January for the wrong cause?…

Read more on Was my dry January for the wrong cause?…

Cancer Research UK’s proposal on Gift Aid reform is by no means perfect

It is good to see Cancer Research UK taking the lead on Gift Aid reform by supporting a 30p composite rate.

It’s an idea that means charities would receive 30p in Gift Aid on every £1 given by a taxpayer, and higher-rate taxpayers would lose the right to claim any personal tax relief on donations.

Progress was needed. Before there can be a sensible debate with the Treasury over reform, there needs to be something to discuss, and the plethora of different options that existed at the start of the year simply weren’t tenable.

However introducing a 30p composite rate would still raise problems. It’s difficult, for instance, to justify labelling a composite rate as tax relief rather than public expenditure.

That’s because the system would mean that if a donor gave £1 to charity, that charity would get an additional 30p even if the donor originally only paid 25p tax to get that £1. Can a tax relief give back more money than the donor originally earned and paid in tax? Or would it have to be called public expenditure?

At present, charities receive 25p as a tax relief on every £1 donation, and then another 3p in public expenditure – transitional relief. That public expenditure can easily be taken away, and in fact it will be in just over a year’s time.

Tax relief, by contrast, is much harder to withdraw, which means that any decision to reclassify Gift Aid as public expenditure would leave the sector vulnerable – and has been ruled out by third sector minister Angela Smith.

It may be possible to label a composite rate as tax relief – an argument between the Treasury and the ONS is going on over this at the moment – but it would not be an easy battle.

It’s also not clear how a composite rate would sit alongside payroll giving. Would payroll giving continue to roll on independently, offering a different system of tax relief to Gift Aid? Or would a giver receive an extra reduction in tax, above and beyond what he paid? Or would it be scrapped altogether? None of these options sound good.

Read more on Cancer Research UK’s proposal on Gift Aid reform is by no means perfect…